Why does my sitemap list broken pages?
Rubric check: sitemap that lists broken pages (check id sitemap_error)
Your sitemap lists addresses that return an error, such as a 404 or a 500. A sitemap should list only live pages you want indexed, so each broken entry is a wasted crawl.
Why it matters for SEO
Search engines use your sitemap to decide what to crawl. Broken entries waste those visits and make the file a weaker guide to your site. Search Console reports them as "Submitted URL not found (404)" or a server error. It usually means pages were deleted or moved but the sitemap wasn't updated.
Does this matter for ChatGPT and AI Overviews?
AI tools rely mostly on search indexes, so the effect is indirect: a clean sitemap helps the right pages get crawled and refreshed. A page that errors can't be indexed or cited whatever the sitemap says.
How Rubric scores it
StandardStandard checks are the baseline every other tier is measured against.
Why this tier: Sitemap lists broken pages.
It is judged on every page Rubric scores.
Every Rubric score starts at 100. When this check fails, it takes up to 12 points off. Even one failing page costs at least 6 points (half of the most), and the rest comes off as the share of affected pages grows. A warning costs less than a failure.
This check doesn't cap your score. It only takes off its own points.
From the engine's scoring files, scoring 2026-v2.1 (engine d5c591d).
How common it is
Found on 24 of 266 sites where Rubric could judge it (9.0%). That is 24 of 254 judged sites in Rubric's 313-site test set and 0 of 12 sites audited on Rubric between 11 Nov 2026 and 17 Nov 2026 under the current check rules (scoring 2026-11k or later). Measured 17 Nov 2026 with scoring 2026-v2.1.
How accurate the check is
Lab test: passed. On test pages built with this problem, it caught 3 of 3. On clean test pages, it stayed quiet 2 of 2 times. (Engine build bbcec7c.)
Real sites: people checked 39 of its findings by hand and 6 were wrong (15%). Last checked 14 Nov 2026.
Holdout test 5 (sites the check had never seen): 0 of 17 findings judged wrong.
Lab as of 16 Nov 2026; judged findings as of 15 Nov 2026.
How to fix it
WordPress
- Sitemaps from WordPress, Yoast SEO and Rank Math update themselves when you delete or unpublish a post. Broken entries usually come from a cache or a hand-made sitemap file.
- Clear your cache plugin and CDN, then reload the sitemap.
- For each broken URL, restore the page or add a 301 redirect to its replacement with a redirect plugin.
- If a static
sitemap.xmlfile sits in your site's root folder, delete it or regenerate it so the plugin's sitemap is used.
Shopify
Shopify builds /sitemap.xml for you and you can't edit it. Deleted and unpublished items drop out on their own.
- If a broken URL appears, check whether the item is still published to the Online Store sales channel but its page errors.
- Fix or redirect the page: search for URL redirects in the admin and add one.
Webflow
- With Auto-generate sitemap on (Site settings > SEO > Indexing), draft and archived items are left out for you. Re-publish the site to refresh it.
- If you use a custom sitemap in that panel, edit it and remove the broken addresses.
- Add 301 redirects for moved pages in Site settings > Publishing > 301 redirects.
Custom code
Build the sitemap from the same data that decides which pages exist, so deleted pages leave it at once. Then check every entry returns 200:
curl -s https://example.com/sitemap.xml | grep -o '<loc>[^<]*' | sed 's/<loc>//' | xargs -n1 curl -o /dev/null -s -w "%{http_code} %{url_effective}\n"Restore, redirect or remove each one that doesn't.